When I wrote
part one of "I Read the News Today, Oh Boy" - way back in July
of last year, I didn't necessarily expect to be writing a part two.
But, "oh boy," do I see a disturbing trend.
"Yesterday, all my troubles seemed so far away"
Increasingly, more than a few newsletters in my inbox have become
little more than thinly veiled self-promotion. Lighter content and
heavy selling has resulted in less and less of a differentiation
between email promotions and email newsletters. This means that
email marketers are missing out on an opportunity to leverage two
different kinds of email communication to their fullest potential.
So, what's the difference between an email promotion and an
email newsletter?
In a nutshell, email promotions are primarily one-way
communications designed to achieve the short-term goal of driving
traffic and sales. An email promotion generally contains one or more
direct calls-to-action "click here to buy now," or "sign up today"
to elicit immediate action on the part of recipients.
Promotions can:
- Help you get your share of holiday business
- Boost sales, appointments or traffic in otherwise slow
months
- Promote your brand
- Clear space for new stock
- Move excess inventory
- Get your name in front of a new or existing customer
- Reward your most loyal customers
Email newsletters, on the other hand, are regularly scheduled
communications that encourage a two-way "conversation." While a
newsletter can contain some calls-to-action that provide short-term
benefits, it is uniquely suited to accomplish the long-term goals of
customer retention and loyalty.
Newsletters can:
- Build relationships with your customers and prospects
- Position your company as a valuable resource
- Obtain and retain the mind share of your customers
- Educate and inform
- Build your credibility over time
- Widen your audience via "word-of-mouth"
- Help you get your share of holiday business
Both email promotions and email newsletters have their place. My
advice is to use both in your
email marketing plan, but treat them differently to maximize the
value of each communication type.
How, you ask?
- Manage Expectations
When your visitors sign up for a newsletter, a newsletter is
what they expect to receive. So, do not use the word
"newsletter" as a clever disguise for your promotions. If
you are hoping to increase your signup rate by duping your
audience, expect the corresponding unsubscribe rate to be as
high - or even higher. Better to just tell it like it is.
Your subscribers will appreciate your honesty and reward you
with their trust and ongoing readership.
- Separate Your Lists
Keep your newsletter lists and promotion lists separate
(it's fine if you have individuals who subscribed to both
lists). Some of your subscribers know they want to take
action and are looking for your promotions. Some may not be
ready to take action just yet. Win them over with your
newsletter content.
- Know Why You're Writing It
Starting a newsletter because your competition has one is
not a good enough reason all by itself. It is very important
to clearly define your newsletter's purpose.
Here's an example that should look familiar:
Email Marketing Hints & Tips is a short email, sent
every three weeks, on the best practices of email
marketing. It includes actionable hints and tips in a
crisp and concise format aimed at helping you become an
expert email marketer!
Trust me, it will let your readers know what to expect
and keep you on track and on topic.
- Give Subscribers a Reason to Read It
A newsletter may have ads and links, but recipients will
open each issue and read it for the content. Our good friend
and newsletter expert, Michael Katz, has his own 80/20 rule:
"80% of your newsletter should be focused on helping the
reader, 20% should be about you."
So provide real value in the form of useful information.
Solve a problem, discuss a hot topic or give actionable
tips. The time you invest in writing the content will be
well spent.